Took the first pages of a new YA to my critique meeting this week. I was very nervous. The problem with starting a new novel is that you end up living with it for a LOOONG time. You have to love it enough to spend months (or years) with it. And your critique group has to live with it too, which makes it even harder to show it to your peers the first time.I had the last critique slot. “What did you bring?” April asked as I passed out copies. We only do 10 pages at a time so we never get to read a full novel. But it’s useful in a way quite different from my online novel critique group (there we read a full novel ms every month--so every five months you get to submit a complete manuscript.) At Onwords & Upwords (the name of this group) the focus is more on a close reading of a small sample. Not great for story arc or plot holes, but awesome for voice.
“It’s new,” I said. I was one copy short so passed them all out--didn’t feel like reading aloud anyway. I focused instead on a handout someone had brought in. Also tried not to peek (and failed!) as they read my pages.
Meanwhile, Amy scribbled furiously at the end of my prologue, Joann read with a slight frown, Sue flipped back several pages, Kate made quiet notes, Natalie read calmly, her face impassive, April did too. The clock ticked. I figured out that the reason the handout didn’t make sense was because I was holding it upside down.
“OK, the prologue threw me,” Sue said. “But maybe that’s just me.”
“It’s the pronouns,” Kate said. “you have to clarify the 'theys', Nandini.”
“I like it,” said April (April likes everything!!!)
“It made sense after I went back and reread it though,” Sue added.
*Deep breath*
So we went back and forth. Sure, there were issues, but they liked it overall.
*Whew*
But. “You know, at the end?” April said. “It sounds a bit like …”
*BINGO*
“Leela,” I finished. (FYI, Leela is the mc of my last YA historical.)
“I know,” I said. “I’m hoping to find Katyani soon. I just have to live with the story longer.”
And so I do. For this reason I have to cut down on the internet for a while. It’s a constant distraction. Doesn’t help that I’m all antsy because of the submission process too. I need some time alone with the new ms so I can find Katyani’s authentic voice. I just have to listen really hard and pay attention.
So it’s goodbye to the blog for now. I’ve promised myself that I’ll be back once I’ve got 15-20K words done. April, perhaps? (Er … the month, not the person!)
We shall see …